Over 75% of homes in Hampshire have a collection of recyclables
Beacon Council Information

Open Day Two Workshops

Beacon Council Sustainable Development - Dealing with Waste

Notes from Workshop F
Adrian Richardson, Southampton City Council

Session 1

Current constraints to closing the environmental and economic loop.

  • Lack of money
    - cost of collection, disposal and recycling
    - up front cost of local infrastructure
  • Knowledge
    - Background
    - For decision making
  • Recycling rate/annual waste arisings
  • Annual waste increase
  • Lack of incentives to reduce
  • Complexity of the issues
  • Lacking in local government
    - Skills
    - Officer time
    - Infrastructure
  • Technical processes involved, but treated as waste rather than manufacturing
  • Waste is not treated as a resource
    - Public perception issue
    - Culture issue
    - Word "waste" is a problem
  • WDA/WCA conflict – structure of local government
    - 2 tier system is a problem – need to work together on sources of supply and markets
  • Awareness of waste – need to analyse
  • Markets. Are the markets there?
    - Lack of reprocessing plants
    - Monopolies in certain materials
    - Pricing fluctuations a problem
    - Reprocessors make the rules
    - Affected by supply and demand
  • The risk needs to be shared - partnerships between LA/industry
  • Costs of collection and disposal going up – recycling contributes to budget but council tax going up so public can’t see financial benefit.
  • Need investment to change the financial equation
  • Financial constraints – can’t charge for household waste by weight.
  • Global economy – imports of eg paper from Germany mean less demand/lower price for local materials
  • Achievement not vision is the problem
  • The waste industry is focussed on landfill

Session 2

What LAs can do to close the loop at local level over the next 10 years

  • Lack of money
    - Bid for more
    - Landfill tax
    - Recycling credits
    - Prioritise LA budgets
  • Increase markets
    - LA role in assisting development, as facilitators – planning departments
    - Collecting material required by markets – the right material
    - Sorting to isolate right material
    - Provide security of supply – quantity and composition. Market fluctuations a problem but most contracts have force majeur clause
    - Constantly monitor composition of waste stream/materials supplied
    - Dialogue with local chambers of commerce
    - Coordinate sharing of information countrywide
    - Help from WRAP/SEEDA
  • Economic development
    - First explore existing links with businesses
    - Should be a strong government strategy with policy statements, and also with flexibility to take into account local conditions
    - Public/private partnership
    - Incentive – provide cheap recycled material
    - Expand new usage locally
    - Investment
    - Use greater proportion of landfill tax for local environmental projects

Session 3

Three practical solutions to close the loop locally
PLASTICS
Discussion:

  • Suggestion for Hampshire
    - PI /plastic processor partnership to set up plant in Hants
    - How big an area to supply it? More than one county?
    - Location near MRF
    - Over capacity in processing
    - Costly to set up in the south
    - Needs to be an incentive
    - Could do part of the process locally – plastic chips
  • Look at materials being used by local businesses – research
  • Counties to join forces in regional partnership – economies of scale for processing plant locally
  • - Local authorities partnership; several counties
    - Environmental considerations
    - Can satisfy environmental targets/regulations from commercial waste stream
    - Sufficient tonnage needs to be collected
    - Need to determine what to take from domestic waste stream – eg bottles only
    - Interest from reprocessor to make chips only to sell to other markets

  • Strategy to include ERI
    - Public perception – plastics (from oil) ® energy (oil is a fuel); appropriate process
    - Needs careful handling
    - Local
    - Must not affect recycling
    - Politics – small and local for planning consent
  • Proximity to existing MRFs/processing companies
    - Weigh benefits of local processing (+ cost) against transporting (may be cheaper)
    - SEEDA role to help development in the SE
    - Far East is competitive alternative
    - Global economy
    - Regional solution – possibly 3-4 plants in country
  • Enlist Universities/Higher Education to find new products - need to introduce high selling product.
  • Large scale operations for funding – focus to get going
  • Different types of plastic eg PEN
  • Supermarket process to reduce volume of plastic. Take back scheme
  • Technically possible to combine plastics to produce new product, but can’t successfully sell end product.
    - Cost
    - End product then recyclable?
  • Collection/processing/markets need to be considered as a whole.
    - More money directed to collection

Three solutions:

  1. Multi partnership group
  • Regional basis - counties to join forces for economies of scale.
  • Collect only types of plastic required (bottles)
  • produce sufficient tonnage to attract reprocessor to make plastic chips only
  • Produce a product for the global market.
  1. Regeneration (Energy Recovery)
  • Strategy should include ERI and public perception be changed
  • Oil (fuel) used to produce plastics, eventually plastic waste used as fuel to produce energy.
  • Must not affect recycling.
  • Keep small and local for planning consent.
  1. Collect, separate and send to the best economic market
  • Global economy
  • Often cheaper to transport and sell abroad than to process locally
  • the Far East is a competitive alternative.

……

  1. Compact the plastics and save underground for mining later when oil is scarce or reprocessing more efficient.
 
Home | Waste Facts | Recycling in Hampshire
News and Events | Contacts and Links | Search

Site Contents © 2000 Project Integra, Hampshire County Council.
Contents correct at date of publication.
Web Design by Alchemy Digital

Web Space provided by Hampshire County Council